BASEBALLKEEP
Dynasty · Redraft · Diamond
Player File · SP BOS
Payton Tolle
#70 · SP · Boston Red Sox · age 23 · B/T LL · 6' 6" / 250 lbs · MLB debut 2025 · Stillwater, USA
Pitching
| Year | G | GS | W | L | SV | HLD | IP | K | BB | HR | ERA | WHIP | K/9 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 21 | 21 | 8 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 120.0 | 134 | 33 | 13 | 3.08 | 1.08 | 10.05 |
| 2025 | 7 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 16.1 | 19 | 8 | 5 | 6.06 | 1.59 | 10.47 |
Plus
- Keep #63 on the 300. Tradable, not a 1.01.
- BK's Pitchers #17 — ace-room capital.
- Age 23 — still climbing the curve.
- On 23 boards — not a one-list darling.
- 3.08 ERA in 120.0 IP. The arm is doing the job this year.
Minus
- Board spread is 48 ranks. You are betting with one camp, not a unanimous tape.
BaseBallKeep Take
Payton Tolle is #63 on BaseBallKeep's overall dynasty 300, a 23-source mix anchored by RotoGraphs (Aug 14) and The Dynasty Guru points list (Aug 10). SP for BOS. BK's Pitchers #17. Rest-of-season redraft #66. MLB since 2025. From Stillwater / USA. Bats L, throws L.
BK Value on this rank is 2,047. Same decaying curve as football: 12,000 at 1.01, a late first a fraction of that. If someone is asking for two firsts, run the calculator. 2026 line: 3.08 ERA, 1.08 WHIP, 134 K in 120.0 IP.
The 23-board average is 64.91 on 23 lists that actually ranked him — unranked sources are skipped, never treated as 999. High 45, low 93.
Dynasty pays the next five years. Redraft pays September. If those two ranks diverge, that is the instruction: hold the kid or cash the veteran.
Flags fly forever. We will refresh this file with The Keep. September baseball is a proving ground, not a coronation.
Every Board
Spread 45–93 · 23 sources
| Source | Rank |
|---|---|
| Pitcher List | 45 |
| TDG Points | 48 |
| Dynasty League Baseball | 56 |
| Four-Seam Fantasy | 56 |
| Razzball | 58 |
| Fantasy Baseballers | 58 |
| Enos Slaughter | 58 |
| FantasyPros Dynasty ECR | 62 |
| CBS Sports | 64 |
| Ottoneu | 64 |
| Baseball Prospectus | 65 |
| The Dynasty Dugout | 65 |
| Baseball America | 65 |
| MLB Pipeline mix | 65 |
| ESPN | 66 |
| NFBC ADP | 66 |
| Mastersball | 66 |
| Yahoo Fantasy | 66 |
| ATC ROS | 66 |
| The Athletic | 71 |
| RotoWire | 85 |
| FanGraphs The Board | 85 |
| RotoGraphs Model | 93 |
On the Wire
Dynasty Wire P14: Young Red Sox arm. Stash, do not stream.
On The Keep nearby — Zack Wheeler (#61) · Colson Montgomery (#62) · Riley Greene (#64) · Jesús Luzardo (#65)
Same position on the 300 — Paul Skenes #5 · Jacob Misiorowski #7 · Tarik Skubal #12 · Cristopher Sánchez #16 · Garrett Crochet #18 · Yoshinobu Yamamoto #24
All players · The Keep · The Lineup · Pitchers · Calculator